That's alot. I got my fenders for $199.00 shipped. Don't know about painting mine was done along with a lot of other stuff. All the have to do is fit the fender and paint, no bending is required.
Was that $199 shipped for both fenders, or was it $199 for each fender? If that was the total cost for both fenders, that would mean that the body shop would be charging you around $300 - $400 for the paint/install. A little steep IMO.