Number 2. And get 19's. I've got 8,5x19 with a 30 offset all around. The car is dropped about 60mm front and 70mm rear, and there is no scrubbing. 235/35 tyres.
And no need to listen to people saying you need a body kit to run 19's. Here's a shot (about the only one I have) of my car, without any body kit what so ever:
Does that really look bad?
And my cellphone resting on the lip of one of the rims: