andy's vinyl overlays are a cost-conscience way of modding your car to get a similar look.
however, the TRD
eyelids are obviously better, more durable and therefore will last longer (vinyl lasts about 7-9 years while Fiberglass eyelids are lifetime--however, most people do not keep their cars 7-9 years anyway)
if you can afford it and you really want them: get the TRD
my advice (coming from someone who is not a fan of eyelids): buy andy's overlays and use the money you would save elsewhere